Question!!!
Moderators: R D Carnegie, Kristi Denney, Jerry Moll, Shane Patton, Chris Freiberger
-
- Starting Member
- Posts: 44
- Joined: Wed Nov 14, 2012 1:27 pm
- PKC Name: Brett Denney
- City, State: Shellman, GA
- PKC Member Since: 06 Jan 2004
- Annual Membership Expires: 22 May 2024
- Lifetime Handler Earnings: $116,662
- Cell #: 2293475776
- Contact:
Question!!!
How can a panel scratch a dog for the 15 when the handler is with the judge going to score trees and the handler don't even know the 15 is on him!!!!!not trying to stir nothing up but real curious on the feedback I might get thanks
-
- Starting Member
- Posts: 44
- Joined: Wed Nov 14, 2012 1:27 pm
- PKC Name: Brett Denney
- City, State: Shellman, GA
- PKC Member Since: 06 Jan 2004
- Annual Membership Expires: 22 May 2024
- Lifetime Handler Earnings: $116,662
- Cell #: 2293475776
- Contact:
Re: Question!!!
Even if he knows the 15 is on him the dog is not with the cast he with the panel my question what if he did leave long enough to break the time the judge dnt know
-
- Bronze Member
- Posts: 161
- Joined: Fri Dec 27, 2013 1:31 pm
- PKC Name: Brandon Glass
- City, State: Iola, TX
- PKC Member Since: 20 Jul 1994
- Annual Membership Expires: 24 Mar 2021
- Lifetime Handler Earnings: $11,719
- Cell #: 936 348 8491
- Contact:
Re: Question!!!
Heck I'm curious to know how a walking panel member goes from panel member to back up judge back to panel member. It's heck when a fella gets you scratched and you question it then he's sitting on the panel.
GCH Little Miss Dottie
WCH Thousand Dollar Bill
WCH Thousand Dollar Bill
-
- Starting Member
- Posts: 49
- Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2005 6:37 pm
- PKC Name: Mark Sullivan
- City, State: Middleton, TN
- PKC Member Since: 20 Apr 1993
- Annual Membership Expires: 01 Dec 2023
- Lifetime Handler Earnings: $101,098
- Location: Walnut MS
- Contact:
Re: Question!!!
I am curious to know as well...
Sounds like a bunch of B.S. Went on..!
Sounds like a bunch of B.S. Went on..!
PCH BSC AMERICAN EXPRESS
-
- Bronze Member
- Posts: 326
- Joined: Thu Sep 10, 2009 12:26 pm
- PKC Name: Daniel Bond
- City, State: Milton, TN
- PKC Member Since: 13 Mar 2008
- Annual Membership Expires: 06 Dec 2018
- Lifetime Handler Earnings: $5,428
- Location: Milton, TN
- Contact:
-
- Starting Member
- Posts: 49
- Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2005 6:37 pm
- PKC Name: Mark Sullivan
- City, State: Middleton, TN
- PKC Member Since: 20 Apr 1993
- Annual Membership Expires: 01 Dec 2023
- Lifetime Handler Earnings: $101,098
- Location: Walnut MS
- Contact:
Re: Question!!!
Rules were broken..
Now I hear their going to be changed
Sounds like other KC
Now I hear their going to be changed
Sounds like other KC
PCH BSC AMERICAN EXPRESS
-
- Bronze Member
- Posts: 272
- Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 1:34 pm
- PKC Name: Jeremy D. Houchin
- City, State: Martinsville, IN
- PKC Member Since: 03 Oct 2002
- Annual Membership Expires: 26 Sep 2024
- Lifetime Handler Earnings: $21,372
- Location: Martinsville, IN
- Contact:
Re: Question!!!
This might be one of the most interesting judgement calls made since i have followed these hunts. How could a panel member make the call to run the 15 and scratch a dog when they aren't even a part of the cast until there is a question brought to them?
Jeremy Houchin
-
- Bronze Member
- Posts: 425
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2003 9:27 am
- PKC Name: Andy Futrell
- City, State: Jewett, TX
- PKC Member Since: 08 Aug 1983
- Annual Membership Expires: 17 Jan 2024
- Lifetime Handler Earnings: $29,903
- Location: Jewett, TX
- Contact:
Re: Question!!!
Sounds like 15 put on dog part of cast goes to score another tree and the dog with the 15 on him stayed with the other cast members is that what happened
Andy Futrell 8088 GCH ScarFace Lil. Sch BackWater Stroker Sch Mr Whitey. Ch Stylish Harry 14. stylish Candy. Old Red Headin South. Ch Whiskey River whoo
-
- PKC National Director
- Posts: 170
- Joined: Sat Sep 11, 2010 5:34 am
- PKC Name: Steve Yant
- City, State: Sikeston, MO
- PKC Member Since: 07 Jul 1984
- Annual Membership Expires: 30 Jun 2027
- Lifetime Handler Earnings: $363,083
- Location: East Prairie, MO
- Contact:
Re: Question!!!
Panel is only there for questions I don't know what happened but a panel can't do anything but solve a question.
I like one that makes you feel lonely
-
- Bronze Member
- Posts: 102
- Joined: Tue Sep 21, 2010 7:35 am
- PKC Name: Cj Thomas
- City, State: Marshall, NC
- PKC Member Since: 07 Jun 2004
- Annual Membership Expires: 29 Mar 2023
- Lifetime Handler Earnings: $31,806
- Cell #: 8282064431
- Location: Marshall, NC
- Contact:
Re: Question!!!
Brett that's about as sketchy as that coon that got scored in the last few min of the hunt I'm not much for stirring trouble but that pro hunt wasn't in a good location nor was there enough quality judges and guides
CJ Thomas!
828-206-4431
828-206-4431
-
- Starting Member
- Posts: 44
- Joined: Wed Nov 14, 2012 1:27 pm
- PKC Name: Brett Denney
- City, State: Shellman, GA
- PKC Member Since: 06 Jan 2004
- Annual Membership Expires: 22 May 2024
- Lifetime Handler Earnings: $116,662
- Cell #: 2293475776
- Contact:
Re: Question!!!
X2 Cj I want be back that's for sure
-
- Bronze Member
- Posts: 102
- Joined: Tue Sep 21, 2010 7:35 am
- PKC Name: Cj Thomas
- City, State: Marshall, NC
- PKC Member Since: 07 Jun 2004
- Annual Membership Expires: 29 Mar 2023
- Lifetime Handler Earnings: $31,806
- Cell #: 8282064431
- Location: Marshall, NC
- Contact:
Re: Question!!!
I understand your not always gonna get what your want every draw that's just part of it... and one bad cast isn't gonna stop me from going to the hunts... but it is a little discouraging when you drive that far and pay $300 to hunt hills ( which I live in mnts ) first round the judge and guide did a awesome job my dog was a mile behind the truck treed the entire hunt i couldn't hear him ( it happenes) 2nd round we had a kid for a pro hunt judge no offense to him... the guide takes us to a spot says the interstate is a mile i look on my garmin and interstate 75 is 900 yards i refuse to cut we go to another place where we cross a 3 strand electric fence 6 times that night my dog was 1.4 treed for over a hour couldn't hear him. after that spot the guide has no where else to take us so we go back to the club for a panel on a question and to get another guide who takes us just up the road from the first place i refuse... he said i hunt my dogs in here all the time and if they run junk they need killed anyway i said out of 64 dogs here you would prob kill 50 of them then... he said your right i would there is a holler over yunder full of them deer running sum lol then the last tree we scored i was out of it completely so it wasn't my fight but i seen a coon get scored that wasn't there it ended up screwing brett i was standing with the Austin kid that won ( nice kid with a nice dog by the way) when he said here he is there was over 7 min gone on shine time im standing there looking in the tree the judge walks over barley gets his light flipped up in the tree and said i seen him crawl up the limb! i was standing right beside him shinning the entire time there might have been a coon there but it wasn't on that limb i promise... and im not taking up for brett cause we are friends i barley know him actually first time ive ever talked to him. IM sure this happens more that one thinks BUT ITS WRONG!!! THATS WAY TO MUCH MONEY TO SPEND TO GET THE SHAFT THAT WAY
CJ Thomas!
828-206-4431
828-206-4431
-
- Bronze Member
- Posts: 153
- Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2010 12:15 pm
- PKC Name: Robert Anderson
- City, State: Millers Creek, NC
- PKC Member Since: 16 Jun 2004
- Annual Membership Expires: 08 Dec 2023
- Lifetime Handler Earnings: $3,916
- Cell #: 336-927-6576
- Location: Millers Creek,NC
- Contact:
Re: Question!!!
Ok I am kinda confused about all this tell me if I am right or wrong if a dog stands there with you for 15 mins aren't you scratched
-
- Gold Member
- Posts: 1132
- Joined: Wed Mar 05, 2003 7:21 am
- PKC Name: Bill Andrews
- City, State: Blytheville, AR
- PKC Member Since: 23 Jul 1984
- Annual Membership Expires: 11 Aug 2022
- Lifetime Handler Earnings: $5,351
- Location: Blytheville, AR
- Contact:
Re: Question!!!
Why didn't the panel go with the judge to score the tree? There might have been a question at that tree.
PKC Proud #32
-
- Silver Member
- Posts: 847
- Joined: Tue Mar 11, 2003 10:37 pm
- PKC Name: Randy Steadman
- City, State: Carlisle, SC
- PKC Member Since: 22 Oct 1992
- Annual Membership Expires: 23 Jul 2024
- Lifetime Handler Earnings: $47,078
- Location: Kingsport, TN
- Contact:
Re: Question!!!
I AM SURE PKC WILL MAKE IT RIGHT